
Clean Shipping Alliance Questions Scientific Basis of Greenland's Scrubber Ban
Cubierto por 3 fuentesPublicado
The Clean Shipping Alliance (CSA), a coalition of shipowners that support the use of exhaust gas scrubbers, has questioned the scientific basis for Greenland's decision to introduce phased restrictions on scrubber washwater discharges. Greenland's Parliament (Inatsisartut) unanimously approved the ban, which will apply from July 1, 2027 to open-loop scrubbers in ports, internal waters and territorial waters, and will be extended from July 1, 2029 to all systems, including closed-loop and hybrid units.
Andreas Chrysostomou, Executive Director of the CSA, expressed disappointment at the announcement and stated that while protecting the Arctic marine environment is important, it remains unclear what specific risk Greenland identified or how it was assessed. The organization referred to IMO circular MEPC.1/Circ.899, which sets out a method for assessing local risks by taking into account discharge composition, dilution, ecotoxicity and the characteristics of the receiving environment, and asked Greenland to publish any assessment carried out under that framework. According to the CSA, a precautionary approach cannot substitute for such an assessment, and it cited a peer-reviewed study on Puget Sound that, under real operating conditions, found low or negligible risks.
The organization also raised concerns about extending the restrictions to territorial waters, beyond what is recommended by the OSPAR Commission, and about the inclusion of closed-loop and hybrid systems starting in 2029, arguing that each technology should be assessed on the basis of its own evidence. The CSA noted that Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI recognizes scrubbers as an equivalent means of compliance with sulphur limits, and argued that any change to that framework should go through a transparent process at the IMO, backed by site-specific scientific evidence, ahead of the discussions scheduled at the Sub-Committee on Pollution Prevention and Response (PPR 14).
The CSA also pushed back on the argument that scrubbers merely shift pollution from air to sea, maintaining that these systems reduce sulphur, particulate matter, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and metals released into the atmosphere, particularly in areas near ports. Citing a 2021 analysis by CE Delft, it noted that refining marine gas oil (MGO) can increase life-cycle CO2 emissions by 10% to 25%, compared with an additional 1.0%-1.5% from operating scrubbers, and referenced a 2025 study submitted to the IMO as PPR 13/INF.6, which found that heavy fuel oil combined with scrubbers could have an environmental impact equal to or lower than VLSFO and MGO across most of the categories assessed. On that basis, it questioned whether the Nuuk-Reykjavik green corridor, which would rely on MGO, can automatically be considered environmentally preferable.
Greenland's decision comes amid a broader push for similar restrictions: Denmark, Sweden and Finland banned open-loop scrubber discharges in their territorial waters last year, and a separate restriction on open-loop and hybrid discharges in North-East Atlantic ports and internal waters will take effect in mid-2027. Environmental organizations, including the Clean Arctic Alliance, welcomed Greenland's move and called for similar restrictions across the Arctic, as well as an eventual global ban through the International Maritime Organization.



